David Vaver, longtime prof of intellectual property law, thinks one reason that judges of the Supreme Court of Canada disagree so much when interpreting copyright law is that the law itself is incomprehensible. The judges don’t know where the government is coming from, let alone where it’s going, he says. He presents the arguments for rewriting IP law from the ground up in a 35 page essay in Volume One of the new Osgoode Hall Review of Law and Policy .